.
Feedback

Secession? Nothing New to the Hudson Valley

The concept of splintering off from a larger government has a history in Westchester and Rockland.

Lower Hudson Valley residents may be viewing the latest national hubbub with one eyebrow raised.

A spate of petitions on the official White House website have residents from all 50 states calling for secession on the heels of President Obama's re-election.

The forms have accrued around 500,000 signatures, but few seem to think the petitions are anything more than posturing, or sour grapes—a slew of state governors have publicly dismissed the appeals, including Texan Rick Perry.

But Westchester and Rockland residents can't quite thumb their noses—secession on a smaller scale sliced up the two counties into what we know today.

West of the Hudson, the sheer number of Nyacks—West, Central, South and Upper—hint at a divisive past.

South Nyack seceeded from Nyack in 1878, just six years after the village incorporated. The reason? Unfair tax distribution, residents said. And in 2011, Upper Nyack residents explored the possibility of pulling away from the Town of Clarkstown and asserting independence as a village-town.

Why? Again, taxes.

Secession had a more recent, but less successful, run in Westchester. An ongoing melee over excessive corporate building brought Purchase residents to a boiling point in the 1960s. A group of about 200 vied to incorporate the hamlet as a village and pull away from the Town of Harrison.

In turn, Harrison attempted to become a city—which would have squashed the the secessionists' foray.

All said, neither came to be—and Purchase remains a hamlet of Harrison.

Patch wants to know what you think of states' petitions; sound off in the comments.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Rye Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
RyeBob May 20, 2013 at 01:09 pm
Let's look at the appropriateness of this post. First, it's clearly an ad because it points to aRead More specific insurance agent at a specific agency to contact. Second, it attempts to hide being an ad behind what may be useful information (or not). Third, the "person" who posted it doesn't use their real name. Instead, they use a pseudonym Divorce Information NOW. That doesn’t seem terribly reassuring to me. This the third advertising post on the “announcements” space since Rye Patch converted to the new site layout. Seems a bit of a mess to me. But hopefully someone will come along and figure out who the real poster is, their link to the advertised agent and agency, and then delete the post. After all, if it’s an ad, it should be labeled as such and the poster should pay for having it run. If that doesn’t happen, Patch won’t be able to pay its employees to keep real content on the site.
Aidan May 24, 2013 at 04:41 am
Don't feel so bad. The Patch doesn't even acknowledge that PC is a waterfront community. We've allRead More been shorted.
Liz Giegerich (Editor) May 15, 2013 at 11:36 am
Thanks for the feedback. There was a mix up with photos, but we are working on getting theRead More appropriate Rye banner photo up right now. Thank you.